We are serving some of the best New York style Pizza and Subs since 1972. We offer dine-in or take out service, we promise it's worth the trip. We are open 7 days a week. Come and visit us now!
Get to know Toby's Original Little Italy Pizza
For 41 years we have been serving some of the best New York Style Pizza and Subs in St Petersburg!
News & Articles
Where To Get Delivery in St. Pete on Halloween
Best Pepperoni Pizza in St. Pete and Clearwater
Catering For Labor Day in St. Pete and Clearwater
Restaurants For Gameday in St. Pete and Clearwater
Enjoy the Best Restaurants With Lasagna in St. Pete and Clearwater
Noodle Nosh: Best Pastas & Italian Food from Clearwater to St. Petersburg
Best Places To Eat For July 4th in St. Pete and Clearwater
Best Restaurants For Father's Day in St. Pete
Add to My Connections
Say Something or Ask a Question about Toby's Original Little Italy Pizza
Recommended Ratings & Reviews
Best pizza, garlic knots that are FANTASTIC they even have salads and let me order meatballs with out the sub bread for low carb. Everyone in the family loves this place from 7 years old to 68 years old!!
Pros: FANTASTIC FOOD
Cons: lines - so get there early
Great pizza for a good price.
Rated the Best Pizza in St. Petersburg for as long as I can remember. Great Pizza!!